It all started with a simple question.
“What would you like to drink next?” Mathias, an excellent mixologist at Charlie was a Sinner in Philadelphia, asked Red Rose and me. We had just finished a magical wheatgrass concoction recommended to us by Derek, one of the spot’s regulars, and were hoping to stay on the gin train.
“Something with gin, maybe lemon,” we said decidedly. “Ah, an Aviation,” Mathias replied immediately, and whipped up two Aviation cocktails, placing them in front of us.
As I studied the drink before me, however, I was confused. “Are you sure this is an Aviation?” I asked demurely. “I mean, isn’t it supposed to be blue in color?”
“This is definitely an Aviation,” he nodded vigorously. “Gin, lemon, maraschino. That’s it.” (Note to past self: it’s never a good idea to question your bartender, who generally knows a hell of a lot more about this stuff than you do.)
Still, throughout the next week, our exchange got me thinking about this high-flying libation: How is the Aviation cocktail supposed to be made, and which version tastes the best? Determined to find out, I gathered my books and my buddies—Mr. Five O’Clock, Rachel, Miss Scarlet, and Bourbon Broad—to get to the bottom of this puzzle. What we found on our quest, dear reader, might surprise you.
Read More